Journal of Fine Arts: Visual Arts

Journal of Fine Arts: Visual Arts

The Iconographic Transformation of the Sacred Messenger of the Sacrificial Ritual in the Illustrated Ramayana Manuscripts of the Mughal School: A Case Study of the Freer Gallery Manuscript

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Painting, Faculty of Fine Arts, Shiraz University of Arts, Shiraz, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Museum, Faculty of Archeology and Museum, Shiraz University of Arts, Shiraz, Iran.
Abstract
The Ramayana, together with the Mahabharata and the Puranas, forms one of the foundational texts of India's religious and cultural heritage. Beyond its literary importance, it has played a central role in shaping the visual, religious, and artistic traditions of South Asia. During the reign of the Mughal emperor Akbar (1556–1605), the Persian translation and illustration of the Ramayana became part of a broader cultural policy that promoted dialogue among the diverse religious and ethnic communities of the empire. By encouraging the translation of Sanskrit texts into Persian and commissioning their illustration in the imperial workshops, Akbar created an artistic environment in which Muslim and Hindu painters worked together, exchanged visual traditions, and developed new forms of artistic expression. The resulting Persian illustrated Ramayana manuscripts provide valuable evidence of cultural interaction between Hindu and Persian-Islamic traditions. Among these manuscripts, the Freer Ramayana, commissioned by ʿAbd al-Raḥīm Khān-i Khānān with Akbar's approval and now preserved in the Freer Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C., occupies a special place. One of its most remarkable illustrations depicts the Sacred Messenger of the Sacrificial Ritual, a supernatural figure emerging from the sacrificial fire while presenting a golden vessel containing the divine offering for King Daśaratha and his queens. In comparison with both the Sanskrit narrative and other Mughal illustrated versions of the Ramayana, this image displays notable visual and iconographic differences. These distinctive features make it an appropriate case for examining the transformation of religious imagery within a multicultural artistic environment. Previous studies have mainly focused on the stylistic characteristics, narrative structure, and artistic development of Persian illustrated Ramayana manuscripts. Although the Freer manuscript has been discussed within broader studies of Mughal painting, the iconography of the Sacred Messenger has not been examined independently through Panofsky's iconographic method. This study therefore seeks to analyze the figure's visual characteristics—including skin color, costume, ornaments, and symbolic attributes—and to explain how these features reflect cultural interaction between Hindu and Persian-Islamic artistic traditions during the Mughal period. The research adopts a qualitative, descriptive-analytical approach based on documentary and library sources. Its theoretical framework is Erwin Panofsky's three-stage model of iconographic analysis. At the pre-iconographical level, the visual elements of the selected painting are carefully described. At the iconographical level, these elements are compared with the Sanskrit Ramayana and two contemporary Persian illustrated manuscripts: the Jaipur Royal manuscript and the Hamida Banu manuscript. Finally, the iconological stage interprets the cultural and religious significance of the observed visual changes within the intellectual and multicultural context of Akbar's court. Although the Freer manuscript constitutes the principal case study, the Jaipur and Hamida Banu manuscripts are employed as comparative examples to clarify the process of iconographic transformation. The analysis demonstrates that the representation of the Sacred Messenger in the Freer manuscript underwent significant formal and symbolic transformation. The most striking change concerns the figure's skin color, which is described as black in the Sanskrit text and represented accordingly in the Jaipur manuscript, but appears as saffron-orange in the Freer version. Other differences include modifications in the depiction of the golden vessel, the number of queens attending the ritual, and several compositional details. Comparative examination indicates that the Jaipur manuscript remains closest to the Sanskrit narrative, whereas the Hamida Banu manuscript introduces moderate changes and the Freer manuscript presents the most extensive reinterpretation. These findings suggest that the Muslim painters did not simply reproduce Hindu iconographic conventions but actively reshaped them through their own visual language and artistic experience. The iconological interpretation further indicates that these transformations should not be regarded merely as mistakes or evidence of unfamiliarity with Hindu mythology. Rather, they reflect a conscious process of cultural reinterpretation within the Mughal artistic environment. The use of saffron for the Sacred Messenger's skin is especially meaningful. In Hindu tradition, saffron symbolizes sacred fire, purity, asceticism, wisdom, and spiritual authority, while within Persian-Islamic visual culture similar chromatic associations evoke sanctity, divine light, and spiritual illumination. The altered appearance of the Sacred Messenger therefore represents a deliberate visual translation through which Hindu sacred imagery was reinterpreted using the symbolic vocabulary of Persian-Islamic painting. The comparative analysis also suggests that the extent of iconographic transformation depended on several interconnected factors, including the artists' familiarity with Hindu religious concepts, the symbolic interpretation of color, the cultural environment of the Mughal atelier, and the painters' individual artistic choices. While the Jaipur manuscript preserves a closer relationship with the Sanskrit narrative through the participation of Hindu artists and closer imperial supervision, the Hamida Banu and especially the Freer manuscript reveal greater interpretative freedom. In the Freer manuscript, the painter Nadim reconstructed the Sacred Messenger through a visual language that mediated between Hindu symbolism and Persian-Islamic artistic conventions, creating a distinct iconographic identity for the figure. In conclusion, the Sacred Messenger in the Freer Ramayana should be understood not simply as the illustration of a mythological episode but as visual evidence of cultural negotiation and artistic adaptation during the Mughal period. Its iconographic transformation reflects the emergence of a shared pictorial language in which sacred concepts were creatively reinterpreted rather than mechanically transferred across cultures. By applying Panofsky's iconographic methodology to a previously understudied image, this study demonstrates that the visual changes observed in the Freer manuscript represent a meaningful expression of intercultural dialogue. The findings contribute to a deeper understanding of Mughal painting, Persian illustrated manuscripts, and the broader processes of iconographic transformation and cultural exchange in early modern South Asia.
Keywords
Subjects

Bada'uni, M. A. M., Hashempour Subhani, T., & Saheb, A. A. (2001). Selection of histories [Muntakhab al-tawarikh] (3 vols.). Association of Cultural Works and Elites. (in Persian)
Blurton, T. R. (2007). Hindu Art. The British museum press.
Bolkhari Ghehi, H. (2016). The Wisdom of Indian Art [Hekmat-e Honar-e Hend]. Sureh Mehr Publications. (in Persian)
Das, A.K. (2003). Notes on the Emperor Akbar’s manuscript of the Persian Ramayana. In International Ramayana seminar. (3rd ed). Swastik offset Printer.
Dehejia, V. (1994). The Legend of Rama: Artistic Visions. Marg Publications.
Farooqi, A. (1979). Art of Indian and Persia. B.R. Publishing Corporation.
Goldman, R. P. (1990). The Ramayana of Valmiki: An Epic of Ancient India. Princeton University Press.
Hajianfard, R. (2017). Mughal Miniature Painting: An Analytical Study of The Translated-Illustrated Manuscripts of The Ramayana Rudsar in the Qajar Period [Tahavolat-e tarikhi, ejtemai va eqtesadi-ye Rudsar dar dore-ye Qajar] [Doctoral dissertation, City University Malaysia]. Electronic Dissertations and Theses City University Malaysia (ETDs). [Doctoral dissertation].
Hajianfard, R., & Zekrgoo, A. H. (2023a). Mughal Miniature Painting an Analytical Study of the Akbar’s Ramayana. Kupas Seni, 11(2), 53–66. https://doi.org/10.37134/kupasseni.vol11.2.6.2023
Hajianfard, R., & Zekrgoo, A. H. (2023b). Bridging aesthetics and narrative in the Hamida Banu Ramayana: An exploration of style, technique, and composition. Indic Heritage & Culture, 2(1).
Jalali-Naini, M. R. (1996). India at a Glance: Anthropology, Political History of India, History of Hinduism, and the Origin of the Universe [Hend dar Yek Negah (Mardom-shenasi, Tarikh-e Siasi-ye Hendustan, Tarikh-e Mazhab-e Hendu, Peydayesh-e Jahan-e Hasti)]. Shirazeh Publications. (in Persian)
Krishnan, G. P. (Ed.) (2010). Ramayana in focus (Visual and performing arts of Asia). Asian Civilisations Meuseum.
Mani, V. (1975). Puranic encyclopaedia: A comprehensive dictionary with special reference to the epic and Puranic literature. Motilal Banarsidass.
Markel, S. (2010). Ramayana and related imagery in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art. In G. P. Krishnan (Ed.), Ramayana in focus: Visual and performing arts of Asia (pp. 82–90). Asian Civilisations Museum.
Mahfuzul-Haq, M. (1931). The Khan Khanan and his painters, illuminators and calligraphists. Islamic Culture: The Hyderabad Quarterly Review, 5(4), 621–630. https://criticalcollective.in/ArtHistoryDetail.aspx?Eid=568
Modabber, S., Hashemi, G., & Tabatabaei, Z. (2020). “A comparative study of the demon motif in the illustrations of the Freer Ramayana manuscript and its earlier and contemporary examples from an iconographic perspective” [Barrasi-ye Tatbighi-ye Naghshmayeh-ye Div dar Negareh-haye Noskhe-ye Ramayanaye Freer va Nemuneh-haye Ghabl va Hamzaman ba an az Manzar-e Shemayel-negari]. Journal of Subcontinent Studies, 12(38), 235–260. https://doi.org/10.222111/jsr.2020.5246 (in Persian)
Mubarak, A. F. (1993). Akbarnama [Akbarnameh] (G. Tabatabaei Majd, Trans., 2nd ed.). Institute for Cultural Studies and Research. (Original work published 1596) (in Persian)
Nahavandi, A. B. (1924). Ma'athir-i Rahimi [Ma'aser-e Rahimi] (M. H. Husain, Ed., Vol. 3). Calcutta, India: Asiatic Society of Bengal. (in Persian
Panipati, M. M. (2009). Ramayana [Ramayana] (S. A. Ziaei & S. M. Y. Jafari, Trans.). (1st ed.). Khaneh-ye Farhang-e Jomhuri-ye Eslami-ye Iran. (Original work published 11 AH) (In Persian)
Radhakrishnan, S. (1999). Indian philosophy. Oxford University Press.
Safvi, R. (2013, October 3). Persian Ramayanas. Tehelka Blog. November 12, 2014, from http://blog.tehelka.com/persian-ramayanas
Sardar, M. (2017). The Ramayana and other tales of Rama. In Epic Tales from Ancient India: Paintings from The San Diego Museum of Art.
Sarkar, A. (1999a). Ravana as the tragic hero. In Naragendra K.R. Singh (Ed), Encyclopedia of Hinduism (vol. 21, pp.1720-1732). Anmol.
Sehgal, S. (Ed.) (1991). Encyclopedia of Hinduism (Vols.1-5). Sarup & Sons.
Seyller, J. (1999). Workshop and Patron in Mughal India: The Freer Rāmāyaṇa and Other Illustrated Manuscripts of 'Abd al-Raḥīm. ArtibusAsiae.
Seyller, J. W., Sardar, M., & Truschke, A. (2020). The Ramayana of Hamida Banu Begum, Queen Mother of Mughal India.
Shayegan, D. (2015). Religions and Philosophical Schools of India [Adyan va Maktab-haye Falsai-ye Hend]. Amir Kabir Publications Institute. (in Persian)
Sharma, R.C (1999). Abduction of Sitā. In Nagendra K.R Singh (ed.), Encylopedia of Hinduism (vol.16, pp.1-5). Anmol.
Sheikh, G. (2012). Reading visuals: Timeless Voyages on the Epic Ocean. Art Connect: An IFA Publication, 6(1), 6–29.
Times of India. (n.d.). Why do Indian saints wear saffron colour? Science tells us. Retrieved from https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/health-fitness/photo-stories/why-do-indian-saints-wear-saffron-colour-science-tells-us/photostory/63414644.cms
Topsfield, A. (Ed) (2004). In the Realm of Gods and kings: Arts of India. Philip Wilson Publishers.
Uddin, J. (2011, November 16–30). Emperor Akbar’s Persian Ramayana and Khan-e-Khanan’s copy. The Milli Gazette. http://www.milligazette.com/news/2653-emperor-akbars-persian-ramayana-and-khan-e-khanans-copy
Valmiki, & Tulsidas. (2000). Ramayana: The Oldest Romantic Epic of India [Ramayana: Kohan-tarin Matn-e Hamasi-ye Asheghaneh-ye Hend] (A. Senkeh & A. P. Kash, Trans.). Alast Farda Publications. (Original work published 2000) (in Persian)
Vanamali. (2014). The complete life of Rama: Based on Valmiki’s Ramayana and the earliest oral traditions. Inner Traditions.
Moles and mentors: Utility of the saffron-clad in Vedic India. (n.d.). Vedic Management. https://vedic-management.com/moles-and-mentors-utility-of-the-saffron-clad-in-vedic-india
Verma, S. P. (1999). Flora and Fauna in Mughal art. Marg Publicaion.
Yahaqi, M. J. (1996). A Dictionary of Myths and Narrative Allusions in Persian Literature [Farhang-e Asatir va Esharat-e Dastani dar Adabiyat-e Farsi. Soroush Publications. (in Persian)
Zekrgoo, A. (1998). The Secrets of Indian Mythology (Vedic Gods) [Asrar-e Asatir-e Hend (Khodayan-e Vedaei)]. Fekr-e Rooz Publications. (in Persian)
 
بداؤنی، مولانا عبدالقادر بن ملوکشاه؛ هاشم‌پور سبحانی توفیق و صاحب، احمدعلی. (1380). منتخب التواریخ. ۳ ج. انجمن آثار و مفاخر فرهنگی.
بلخاری ‌قِهی، حسن. (1395). حکمت هنرهند. انتشارات سوره مهر.
پانی‌پتی، مولا مسیح. (2009). رامایان (سید عبدالحمید ضیایی و سید محمد یونس جعفری، مترجمان). چاپ اول. خانه فرهنگ جمهوری اسلامی ایران. (چاپ اثر اصلی 11 ه.ق)
جلالی ‌نائینی، محمدرضا (1375). هند در یک نگاه (مردم‌شناسی، تاریخ سیاسی هندوستان، تاریخ مذهب هندو، پیدایی جهان هستی). انتشارات شیرازه.
ذکرگو، امیرحسین. (1377). اسرار اساطیر هند(خدایان ودایی). انتشارات فکر روز.
شایگان، داریوش. (1394). ادیان و مکتب‌های فلسفی هند. مؤسسه انتشارات امیرکبیر.
مبارک، شیخ ابولفضل. (1372). اکبرنامه (ترجمه غلامرضا طباطبایی مجد، چاپ دوم). موسسه مطالعات و تحقیقات فرهنگی. (چاپ اثر اصلی 1596)
مدبر، ثمین؛ هاشمی، غلامرضا و طباطبایی، زهره. (1399). بررسی تطبیقی نقش‌مایه دیو در نگاره‌های نسخه رامایانای فریر و نمونه‌های قبل و هم‌زمان با آن از منظر شمایل‌نگاری. مطالعات شبه‌قاره، 12(38)، 235–260.
نهاوندی، عبدالباقی (1924). مآثر رحیمی (محمد هدایت حسین، مصحح؛ جلد 3). کلکته هند: انجمن آسیایی بنگال.
والمیکی و داس، تلسی. (1379). رامایانا: کهن‌ترین متن حماسی عاشقانه‌ی هند (ا. سنکهه و ا. پ. کاش، مترجمان). الست فردا. (چاپ اثر اصلی 2000)
یاحقی، محمدجعفر. (1375). فرهنگ اساطیر و اشارات داستانی در ادبیات فارسی. انتشارات سروش.