Study of "Grotesque Body" in Muhammad Siyah Qalem’s Painting on the Basis of Bakhtin's Thought

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 MA in Painting, Art University of Tehran, Tehran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of Allameh Tabatabaei, Tehran

Abstract

The most of the research have done on the subject of Muhammad Siyah qalem, shaped with respect to identity and cultural background of his paintings and works. Muhammad Siyah qalem is a famous painter but anonymous of the second half of the ninth century that, his life and identity is still shrouded in mystery and it is almost the equivalent of a century that has been made context for numerous researches studies. The most of his works has been held in library’s albums from Istanbul Topkapi Palace and, also a few of them have been kept in the freer gallery in Washington and the Metropolitan in New York. His famous is by creation of the demons, humans and shamans, and this article has been helped without concern for identity and cultural context of Muhammad Siyah qalem’s work from the shapes and forms Mikhail Bakhtin’s carnival, and has particularly been investigated Muhammad Siyah qalem’s grotesque world by looking deep and new. And in line with this object, elaborates elements of Muhammad Siyah qalem’s painting that are defined and equality by functions of Mikhail Bakhtin’s grotesque body. Mikhail Bakhtin is a great philosopher and theorist in 20th century that has imposed on his opinions concepts and ideas such as "dialogue" or "dialogism", "the other","polylossia", "polyphonic", "carnival" and etc. His theories almost is two decades that has extended in the visual arts and has built a suitable structure in criticism of these works for art researchers. As respects Mikhail Bakhtin’s specific point of view about carnival and "grotesque body"could be an appropriate approach to analyzing and discussing the grotesque world of Muhammad Siyah qalem. Also Bakhtin’s thought completely distinguishes interpretations before him about "the other", novel, language and its potential forces and brings up in his book Rabelais and His World, concepts of carnival and grotesque realism, and displays in that a function of the body that emphasizes on the relations between the layer and material of the body and the world and reconstruction in the act of becoming, growth, birth and death. This research has been interpreted elements of Muhammad Siyah qalem’s figures by an adaptive and analysis approach that are focused on the functions of Mikhail Bakhtin’s grotesque body. According to Mikhail Bakhtin’s thought, grotesque body is not unique or inimitable and separate from the rest of the world. That is an amorphous and abandoned, unbound body. And everything that happens in its inside, successive associates with life and death and it has never absolute end, also another is that creates another shaper of both the power (power shaping for the another one), a body that doesn’t have an independent and individuality so he/she isn’t separate and a only single body,that was exceeded from the limits of its physical form and joined to the world and  the objects and  the other bodies. Muhammad Siyah qalem’s figures have the potential by these features, for interpretation and description with this combined and unbound body.

Keywords


احمدی، بابک (1386)، ساختار و تاویل متن، مرکز، تهران.
آژند، یعقوب (1386)، استاد محمد سیاه‌ قلم(مفاخر هنری ایران3)، امیرکبیر، تهران.
انصاری، منصور(1384)، دموکراسی گفتگویی، مرکز، تهران. 
باختین، میخائیل (1387)، تخیل مکالمه‌ای (جستارهایی درباره رمان)، ترجمه رویا پورآذر، نی، تهران.
تودوروف، تزوتان (1377)، منطق گفتگویی میخائیل باختین، ترجمه داریوش‌ کریمی، مرکز، تهران.
شکورزاده، ابراهیم (1367)، فرانسوا رابله نویسنده بزرگ و شوخ طبع قرن شانزدهم فرانسه، نشریه‌ دانشکده ادبیات و علوم انسانی مشهد، شماره4، صص552 ـ 538.
طباطبایی، زهره (1382)، استاد محمد سیاه قلم، هنرنامه، شماره 18، صص40 ـ 23.
کریم‌زاده تبریزی، محمدعلی (1376)، احوال و آثار نقاشان قدیم ایران، هند و عثمانی، مستوفی، تهران.
لچت، جان (1380)، پنجاه متفکر بزرگ معاصر، ترجمه محسن حکیمی، خجسته، تهران.
نولز، رونالد (1391)، شکسپیر و کارناوال پس از باختین، ترجمه رویا پورآذر، هرمس، تهران.
هینلز، جان.ر (1386)، شناخت اساطیر ایران، ترجمه احمد تفضلی، ژاله آموزگار، چشمه، تهران.
یاحقی، محمد جعفر (1386)، فرهنگ اساطیر و داستان‌واره‌ها در ادبیات فارسی، فرهنگ معاصر، تهران.
 
Bakhtin, M.M (1984), Rabelais and his World. H. Isowolsky (Tr.), Indiana University Press, Bloomington.
Dentith, S (2005),Bakhtinian Thought: An introductory reader, Routledge, New York.
Smith, Paul and Wilde, Carolyn (2002), Art Theory, Blackwell Publishers Ltd,a Blackwell Publishing company, Blackwell.
Stewart, Alison (1993),Paper Festivals and Popular Entertainment, The Kermis Woodcuts of Sebald Beham in Reformation Nuremberg, Sixteenth Century Journal 24, No. 2, pp 301-350.