phenomenological study of time in conservation and restoration of cultural heritage

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate in Restoration and Conservation of Cultural Heritage, Art University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

2 full professor , architecture Faculty, Tehran University

Abstract

This is a phenomenological study in which phenomenology of time has been accomplished to achieve a theory in the field of restoration and conservation of cultural heritage. The time based on the views of thinkers is considered as the fourth dimension and the principle of the existence of objects, including the principle of the existence of cultural heritage. The main problem of research is that time as the fourth dimension in cultural heritage how can be distinguished and investigated and what is its function in restoration process. For solving this problem the phenomenological methodology is applied. Accordingly, time through event, material culture, place, human and the layers of frazzle in historical and cultural works can be appear and constitute in human consciousness. On the basis of the fundamental relationship of time with the principle of the existence of cultural heritage, it as much as possible the protection of the layers of extinction in historical works as an accumulation of the now layers have been emphasized. Measurement and study of the technology of the layers of historical works and burnout created during the transit of time on the level of historical and cultural monuments based on the principles of temporal of material and its relation to motion and change, the possibility of timeliness studies and pathological analysis in historical and cultural works has been provided. Also, studying and identifying the burnout layers in addition to evidence of time can be effective in choosing appropriate and optimal methods for conservation and restoration in order to preserve the durability of historical and cultural monuments. The phenomenology of time in the field of conservation and restoration of historical and cultural monuments, targeting human beings on its theoretical horizon, answering fundamental questions in the postmodern conservation and restoration, and beyond ordinary studies within the scope of the material analysis of monuments, provides the conservation and restoration with humanity and ultra-material analysis status. Based on the phenomenological method of time, focusing on the concept of event and material culture and their fundamental relationship with time, the preservation and restoration of historical and cultural remnants of the past is in fact the protection and maintenance of time. According to this research, the time in the four stages of the production of historical works, the time elapsed for the historical work as its life, and the time of encountering the historical monuments with consciousness of the restorer, and based on the subjective concepts of time like embodiment and material culture, the human time. Each of which, in the theory of the phenomenology of time has its own particular study position, and when the historical and cultural monuments encounter with the consciousness of the restorer, it is a methodological moment, the moment in which understanding takes place. Understanding the past in terms of the historical and cultural monuments left by it at the present time when this understanding initiates the process of conservation and restoration of these monuments in order to transfer past through the present to the future and coexisting past with the future.

Keywords

References

ابراهیمی­دینانی، غلامحسین ­(­1393)،­ معمای زمان و حدوث جهان، ­مؤسسه پژوهشی حکمت و فلسفه ایران، تهران.
ابراهیمی­دینانی، غلامحسین ­(­1394)، ­از محسوس تا معقول،­ مؤسسه پژوهشی حکمت و فلسفه ایران، تهران.
ابن­سینا،­ حسین­ابن­عبدالله­­ (1375­)، ­­الاشارات و التنبیهات،­ نشر­البلاغه، ­­قم.
ارسطو ­­(1394)، سماع­طبیعی(فیزیک)جلد2،­ ترجمه: محمد­حسن­لطفی، انتشارات­ طرح­نو، تهران.
افلاطون ­(1388)، تیمائوس، ­دوره­آثار­جلد3،­ ترجمه: محمد­حسن­لطفی، انتشارات­ خوارزمی، تهران.
باردون،­ آدریان­(­1395­)،­ تاریخچه ­فلسفه ­زمان، ترجمه:­ حسن ­امیری­آرا،­ انتشارات ­کرگدن، تهران.
اسپیگلبرگ، هربرت و شومان،کارل (1393)، ­­جنبش­ پدیدارشناسی­، درآمدی ­تاریخی، ­جلد2، ترجمه: مسعود علیا، انتشارات­­ مینوی­ خرد،­ تهران.
پریموزیک،­ دنیل­تامس ­(­1388)، ­مرلوپونتی­، فلسفه ­و­ معنا، ترجمه:­ محمدرضا ­ابوالقاسمی، انتشارات ­مرکز، تهران.
­جمادی،­ سیاوش ­­(1395)،­ زمینه و زمانه­ی پدیدار­شناسی،­ جستاری در زندگی و اندیشه­های هوسرل و هایدگر، انتشارات ققنوس، تهران.
جینز،­ جی.،­ اچ­ (1389)، فیزیک­ و فلسفه، ترجمه­:­ علیقلی ­بیانی،­ مرکز­ انتشارات علمی­ و ­فرهنگی، تهران.
دارتیگ،­آندره ­­(1396)،­­ پدیدا­رشناسی ­چیست؟­،­ ترجمه: محمود ­نوالی، انتشارات­ سمت، تهران.
راسل، ­برتراند ­­(1340)،­­ مفهوم نسبیّت اینشتین و نتایج فلسفی آن،­ ترجمه:­ مرتضی ­طلوعی، ­مؤسسه­ی چاپ و انتشارات امیرکبیر، تهران.
راسل، برتراند ­(1394)، ­تاریخ فلسفه غرب، جلد1، ترجمه: نجف­ دریابندری، انتشارات­ پرواز، تهران.
ساکالوفسکی، ­رابرت ­(1395)، ­درآمدی بر پدیدار­شناسی، انتشارات­ گام نو، تهران.
سهروردی، ­شیخ­ شهاب­الدین ­یحیی ­(1377)، ­حکمه­الاشراق، ­ترجمه ­و ­شرح­:­ سیّد­جعفر ­سجادی­،­ انتشارات ­دانشگاه ­تهران، تهران.
سوانه،­ پیر ­(1393)،­ مبانی ­زیبا­شناسی­، ­ترجمه­: ­محمد­رضا­ ابوالقاسمی، نشر­ ماهی، تهران.
صدرالدین­ شیرازی،­ محمد­ابراهیم­ (1392)، ­اسفار اربعه، سفر اول، ترجمه:­ محمّد­ خواجوی، انتشارات ­­مولی، تهران.
صدرالدین ­شیرازی،­ محمد­ابراهیم ­­(1377­)، ­رساله ­الحدوث ­العالم –­کتاب ­آفرینش­ جهان-­ ترجمه:­ محمّد ­خواجوی، انتشارات مولی، تهران.
طباطبایی­،­ محمد­حسین ­­(1335)، ­­اصول فلسفه و روش رئالیسم،­ انتشارات صدرا،تهران.
کانت، امانوئل­(1391)، سنجش ­خرد­ ناب،­ ترجمه: شمس­الدین­ ادیب ­سلطانی، ­انتشارات امیرکبیر، تهران.
لویناس،­ امانوئل ­(1393­)، ­از وجود به موجود، ترجمه: مسعود علیا، انتشارات­­ ققنوس، تهران.
مطهّری، مرتضی­(1366)،­ حرکت ­و زمان، درس­های اسفارجلد2،­ انتشارات­ حکمت، تهران.
وال، ژان ­(1395)، بحث ­­در ­مابعدالطبیعه، ترجمه: یحیی­ مهدوی­ و همکاران، انتشارات ­خوارزمی، تهران.
وودراف ­اسمیت، دیوید ­(1395­)،­­ پدیدار­شناسی­، دانشنامه ­استنفورد1،­ ترجمه: ­مسعود علیا، انتشارات ­ققنوس، تهران.
ویناس،­ سالوادور مونیوس ­(1389)، ­نگره­ی ­نگاهداشت ­معاصر، ترجمه: فرهنگ­ مظفّر ­و ­دیگران، انتشارات­ گلدسته، اصفهان.
هایدگر،­ مارتین ­(1388)،­ مفهوم زمان، ترجمه: نادر نقش­بند، مجیدرنجبر، انتشارات ­پرسش، آبادان.
هایدگر، مارتین ­(­1395)،­ هستی و زمان، ترجمه: عبدالکریم­ رشیدیان، ­نشر نی، تهران.
هایدگر، مارتین ­(1395)،­ مسائل اساسی پدیدار­شناسی، ترجمه: پرویز ­ضیاءشهابی،­ انتشارات ­مینوی ­خرد، تهران.
هوسرل، ادموند ­(1393­)، ایده­ی ­پدیده­شناسی، ترجمه: عبدالکریم ­رشیدیان، انتشارات ­علمی ­و ­فرهنگی، تهران.
 
Adcock, R­ (2003), What might it mean to be an­“Interpretivist”?­Qualitative­methods,1(2), 16-18.
­Agnew, ­Neville & ­­Brigand,­ Janet­ (2006),­Of the past for the future,­Getty conservation institute publication, ­Los­Angeles.
­Avrami, ­Erica; ­Randall,­ Mason & ­de la Torre,­ Marta ­(2000),­Values and Heritage Conservation Research Report, the Getty Conservation Institute publication, ­Los­Angeles.
Bardon, Adrian ­(2013),­­ A Brief History of the Philosophy of Time, Oxford university press, London.
­Brandi, Cezare ­(2005),­ Theory of Restoration,­Instituto Centrale per il Resta,Rome.
­Brown,­ Matthew­ (­2004),­Can the Past and the Future Coexist?, Econ Journal Watch,­ The Independent Review,8(3), ­439-444.
Caple,­ Christopher ­(­2006),­­Objects:­reluctant witnesses to the past, Rutledge, New­York.
­Cresswell, J.,W­ (2005),­ Educational Reasearch:Planning,Coducting,and Evaluating quantitative and qualitative research,­University of Nebraska,Lincoln. 
 Compbell, ­John ­(1997),­The Structure of Time in Autobiographical Memory,­ European Journal of Philosophy­,­5(2­),­­105–118.
 
Davidson, Matthew­ (2004), ­­Four Dimentionalism,­ Analytical philosophy, ­45(1),17-33.
 
De Smedt, Johan & De Cruz, Helen­ (­2011),­ The role of material culture in human time representation: Calendrical systems as extensions of mental time travel, Adaptive Behavior, 19(1), 63-76.
 
Duffrene,­ Mikel ­(1989),­­ The Phenomenology of Aesthetic Experience (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy), Northwestern University Press, Evanston.
Edgren, Lisa ­et al.­ (2017),­ Contemporary Conservation Theory for Sustainable Development of Cultural heritage Objects, The international journal of inclusive museum,10(1), 8-18.
Fell, Elena­ (2012), ­Duration Temporality, ­Self­:­Prospects for the Future of Bergsonism, international academic publishers, Oxford, Peter­Lang, Switzerland.
 Glendinning,­ Simon ­(­2008),­­ What­­ is Phenomenology?, Philosophy compass,­3(1), 30-50.
Gonzalez, Alfredo ­(­2016), ­Archaeology and the Time of Modernity, Historical Archaeology, 50(3), 144-164.
Hegel­,­ Georg Wilhelm Friedrich ­(2011), ­Encyclopädie der philosophischen wissenschaften im Grundrisse,­1830- Die Wissenschaft der Logik. Mit den mündlichen Zusätzen, hrsg.­V.­G. Bolland, ­Leiden.
Horel, ­Christoph­ (1998), ­The Perception of Time and the Notion of a Point of View, European Journal of Philosophy­,­6(2)­,­156–171.
Jones, Andrew­­ (­2007),­ Memory and Material Culture, Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New­York.
 
Kennedy, J., B ­(2014),­Time and Einstein, ­An Introduction, Routledge, New­York.
Le­ Poidevin,­ Robin ­(­1999), ­Recent work on Time,­­ Analytical philosophy,40(1),1-9.
Le Poidevin­, Robin ­(2015),­ The Experience and Perception of Time, in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/time-experience,7/16/2018.
 
 Liritzis, ­Ioannis et al. ­(2013),­Luminescence Dating in Archaeology, Anthropology, and Geoarchaeology An Overview, Springer Cham Heidelberg, New­York, Dordrecht, London.
 
Pearce,­ Susan (2003),­­ Interpreting Objects and Collections, Routledge,Taylor & Francis e-Library, London.
Richmond,­ Alison & Bracker, Alison ­(­2009),­Conservation Principles Dilemmas and Uncomfortable Truths­, Butterworth-Heinemann, Elsevier, Published in association with the Victoria and Albert Museum, London.
Smart, J. J.C ­(1968), Problems of space and time, the Macmillan Company, New­York.
-Torrance, H ­(2008),­ Building confidence in qualitative research, qualitative inquiry,14(4),507-527.
Weismantel, ­Mary & Meskell, Lynn ­(­2014), Substances:‘Following the Material’ through two prehistoric cases, Journal of Material Culture,19(3), ­233-251.
Wright,­ Chris ­(2004),­ Material and Memory: Photography in the Western Solomon Islands, journal of Material Culture,­­(9)­1, 73-85.
 
­Weinert,­ Friedel ­)2013),­ The March of Time, Springer, London.
 
Young, James (­2004), Art and knowledge, published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library Rutledge, London.
Yousefnejad, S (2015), Investigation the glaze deterioration process in Achaemanid glazed bricks of Susa­, in International Symposium on Nondestructive and micro analytical techniques in Art and cultural heritage, TECHNART 2015 – Catania, Italy, April 27-30, 2015.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Journal of Fine Arts: Visual Arts
Volume 24, Issue 1
February 2019
Pages 8-18

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics